Tuesday, July 2, 2013

"Unveiling" The Hiddenness of God

(Last updated/edited 9/17/16)

This blog should be read in conjunction with my other blog HERE.


Truly, you are a God who hides himself,
O God of Israel, the Savior.
– Isaiah 45:15

Many of the various objections to Christianity are directly or indirectly related to the topic of the Hiddenness of God (sometimes abbreviated in this blog as "HoG"). For example, the HoG has bearing on the Problem of Evil and Suffering ("PoE").  PoE is considered by most authorities (philosophical, theological, apologetical,  atheological etc.) to be the number one objection to Christianity [both logically and emotionally]. In recent years many books and essays have been written addressing the HoG. But in comparison to the problem of evil, the HoG has barely been addressed or grappled with. Here are some of my thoughts concerning the HoG. In the following I'll be combining and highlighting the insights that other writers have made with my own comments. Obviously, I won't be able to cover all the worthy contributions made on this topic by better writers.

A basic objection to Christianity based on the HoG is often stated this way, "Why isn't God's existence more obvious and clear? Why hasn't God made His existence undeniable?" For example, why doesn't God use the stars in the sky to write in every major language "I, God, exist and Jesus Christ is my Son"?

In Christianity, God not only created humans, but He also created angels. When He did, He created them in such a way that it was impossible for the angels to not know He existed. That is, they couldn't escape knowing that God exists. The angels had that epistemological advantage of knowing with certainty that God existed. But the disadvantage of that scenario was that their belief, obedience, and devotion to God was, in a sense, "coerced." They didn't have the opportunity to demonstrate their obedience and devotion as being willing and freely committed. That's the exact opposite when it comes to the situation human beings find themselves in.  Unlike Adam and Eve who were directly created by God or Moses and the Exodus generation, humans are generally born in situations where God's existence is not absolutely and rationally certain (or nearly so) or coerced due to strong evidence (e.g. the miracles in Moses' ministry). In that sense, human beings are that much freer (than angels) to willingly choose to believe, obey and be devoted to God despite all obstacles, difficulties and doubts. We humans have the opportunity to show by our daily living that we desire God to exist and are committed to believing and obeying Him, even when it gets difficult to believe or when faith is wavering. Humans get the opportunity to more freely choose for or against God and His ways and whether to willingly serve or disobey Him. Thus, with their lesser knowledge, it allowed for the greater potential praise and reward of humans; just as the angels, with their greater knowledge, resulted in the greater potential for blame and punishment.

Apparently, God chose to make (at least) two kinds of sentient species (angels and humans) under these different circumstances. Two additional differences between the creation of angelkind and humankind are 1. (apparently) each individual angel is created directly by God and is not the offspring of a parental angel or angels; unlike humans who are born from parents of the same species (with the exception of Adam & Eve). 2. (apparently) angels were not created with a Federal Head whose actions had ramifications for each individual. Unlike humans who had Adam as their Federal Head and whose Original Sin had ramifications on the rest of his species (i.e. his wife and descendants).

Above I explained the advantage and disadvantage of the angelic situation as well as the advantage of the human situation. What then is (or are) the human disadvantage(s)?  They can be exemplified in the following questions. "How does one come to know or be convinced of the existence of God? If the evidence for God is not sufficiently strong enough, how can one come to justifiably believe in God, or justifiably be judged by God when His existence wasn't evidently clear?"

I agree with William Lane Craig's following statement regarding the hypothetical situation in which God repeatedly makes his existence rationally coercive (or nearly so) to each individual human. Imagine God speaking in a booming voice every 12 PM noontime in every time zone saying "I, God, exist and Jesus is my Son. Believe in Him." Or imagine a theophany of God following you around and intruding in your most private moments in the bathroom or bedroom. Or personally warning you every time you're tempted to commit some sin. A kind of divine "Big Brother." Craig says,

"Indeed, I could well imagine that in such a world, after a while, people would begin to chafe under such brazen advertisements of their Creator. And in time, eventually come to resent His effrontery for such brazen advertisements of His existence." (paraphrase of a statement he's made in various texts and in debates; e.g. HERE and HERE, similarly HERE)
Apparently, that's what might have happened in the angelic realm. The existence of God was so commonplace that that familiarity bred contempt. It may be asked, "Could not the same thing happen with humans in heaven after countless eons of living in the presence of God?" This delves into a topic that's outside the purpose of this particular blog. But I'll give a brief truncated answer. I speculate that the knowledge of God angels had before any of them fell into sin was probably limited and therefore allowed for the possibility of some of them thinking they can join forces to successfully overthrow and replace God.

 It seems to me that if they fully knew that God was truly omnipotent (i.e. ALL-powerful, not merely VERY-powerful), it would have made little sense for them to attempt to overthrow God. It would be totally irrational to attempt to rebel against an omnipotent Deity. Even 1 Peter 1:12 declares that the angels are learning things about theology and the plan of God as they watch the human drama unfold. The Redemptive History of mankind is not only for the instruction of humans, but also of angels. It may have been that before the angels fell they weren't fully informed, for example, of God's omnipotence or absolute sovereignty (and by extension predestination). That answer might explain how angels COULD fall. Another possibility is that they were told of God's attributes like omnipotence, but they gradually began to doubt that God had the powers He claimed to have because of their limited experience of God. God may have continually manifested Himself to the angels in a theophany whereby He could be seen sitting on a throne. Some of the angels may have wrongly inferred from that theophany that God was limited in the ways they themselves were and so eventually plotted to overthrow God once they started doubting His claimed attributes of omnipotence, omniscience, omnipresence et cetera.

Now how do we go about explaining how redeemed humans in heaven WON'T fall again for a second or third or fourth time (ad infinitum)? While some theologians allowed for repeated falls and redemptions (like Origen), most modern Christian theologians reject the notion. The more Arminian-like theologians often argue that the soul-making property of humanity's earthly life forms and sets (as in the hardening of clay) the character of humans so that by the time they get to heaven it would be impossible for them to fall again. Especially since they are now exposed to the full glory, holiness and grace of God (unlike the angels, per my speculation). That coupled with their being able to appreciate the benefits of redemption after having experienced for a lifetime the misery of a fallen world.

These are things which may have been denied angels by the circumstances of their creation. Yet, they were nevertheless responsible because of the limited knowledge they did have which included the certain knowledge of their Creator and heavenly Father (Heb. 12:9) who was, in their clear observation, (at the very least) extremely powerful and extremely benevolent. Adult human offspring don't normally rebel or conspire against loving parents. Teenage children do, but that's partially due to their rational powers not having yet fully developed. Whereas angels were created extremely intelligent from the start. Stephen Charnock wrote, "Unbelief was the first sin, and pride was the first-born of it." Again, my speculation is that the angels were originally given sufficient knowledge of God that they knew for certain God exists and had certain attributes. But that knowledge of God wasn't complete, though it did render them morally culpable for rejecting God. According to my speculation (and Charnock's quote), "Lucifer" (conventionally named so) or some other angel, first started to doubt God's power and goodness. This doubt spread through angelkind, and in pride one (e.g. Lucifer) or all of them deluded themselves into thinking they could overthrow God and have one in their own ranks take God's place. From the Christian perspective, the attempted coup d'état failed. For all we know, demons still think it's possible to overthrow God and usurp His authority. That might explain why they still fight against God's Kingdom. Another possibility might be that they live in a different timeline since they also live in a different dimension (another speculation), though I'm disinclined to believe it. But that might explain why they continue to fight God even after the Cross and Resurrection of Christ.

Returning to the issue of explaining why the saints in heaven won't fall; the more Calvinistic-like theologians argue that God can so sanctify human beings and conform them to the image of Christ (and His character) such that they will willingly be unable to sin. This answer is similar to one of the Arminian-like answers but is more consistent with Calvinism because Calvinism denies libertarian free will (usually in favor of compatibilistic free will). Given libertarian free will, it is difficult to conceive of finite creatures being unable to sin. But I'll set that issue aside.

To those paying attention to the argument, it might be noted that I still haven't addressed the questions I posed on behalf of my hypothetical critics. As a reminder, here are the questions again,

"How does one come to know or be convinced of the existence of God? If the evidence for God is not sufficiently strong enough, how can one come to justifiably believe in God, or justifiably be judged by God when His existence wasn't evidently clear?"
A beginning answer can be found in a few quotes by Blaise Pascal. He wrote in his Pensées:

Willing to appear openly to those who seek him with all their heart, and to be hidden from those who flee from him with all their heart, God so regulates the knowledge of himself that he has given indications [or "signs"] of himself which are visible to those who seek him and not to those who do not seek him. There is enough light for those to see who only desire to see, and enough obscurity for those who have a contrary disposition. [Quoted by William Lane Craig HERE and HERE]

Elsewhere in his Pensées he wrote:

The prophecies, the very miracles and proofs of our religion, are not of such a nature that they can be said to be absolutely convincing. But they are also of such a kind that it cannot be said that it is unreasonable to believe them. Thus there is both evidence and obscurity to enlighten some and confuse others. But the evidence is such that it surpasses, or at least equals, the evidence to the contrary; so that it is not reason which can determine men not to follow it, and thus it can only be lust or malice of heart. And by this means there is sufficient evidence to condemn, and insufficient to convince; so that it appears in those who follow it, that it is grace, and not reason, which makes them follow it; and in those who shun it, that it is lust, not reason, which makes them shun it. 
God's apparent absence can also be compounded and explained by the fact that God uses relational distance as a form of judgment. Isaiah 59 says,

1    Behold, the LORD's hand is not shortened, that it cannot save,
        or his ear dull, that it cannot hear;
2    but your iniquities have made a separation
        between you and your God,
    and your sins have hidden his face from you
        so that he does not hear.
3    For your hands are defiled with blood
        and your fingers with iniquity;
    your lips have spoken lies;
        your tongue mutters wickedness.
[The remainder of the chapter continues in the same vein]

Another compounding factor in the apparent absence of God is the reality that we ourselves as sinners hide and run away from a holy God like Adam and Eve did because of their guilt and shame. We naturally try to suppress, repress and resist the presence and reality of God.

And they heard the sound of the LORD God walking in the garden in the cool of the day, and the man and his wife hid themselves from the presence of the LORD God among the trees of the garden.– Gen. 3:8
19 And this is the judgment: the light has come into the world, and people loved the darkness rather than the light because their works were evil.20 For everyone who does wicked things hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his works should be exposed.– John 3:19-20
 Or as C.S. Lewis put it in Surprised by Joy, "Amiable agnostics will talk cheerfully about 'man's search for God'. To me, as I then was, they might as well have talked about the mouse's search for the cat."


The beauty of the two quotes I gave of Pascal is that they can be appealed to and used by both Arminian-like Christians and (most) Calvinistic-like Christians (if understood in a particular way by a Calvinist). Even by Van Tillian Calvinists who believe that all things in creation are (in some way) evidence for the existence of God. The evidence for God can be sufficient so that all humans are without excuse, without that evidence having to be rationally coercive. I interpret Van Til to teach that all men know existentially that God exists, rather than knowing in a rationally coercive way. More Pascal quotations can be found at this link HERE


Returning to William Lane Craig's insight, I can imagine that most humans (especially before their salvation) would NOT want God continuously watching them knowing He is also continuously "recording," weighing and judging their thoughts, words, and actions. Most people, because of their sinful nature, wouldn't want a God to exist who sees all the sins they commit (with their "heads," "hearts" and "hands") at work, in their bedrooms, against their families, friends and neighbors and against themselves (not to mention against God Himself).

If God's existence were clearly evident people would end up either begrudgingly feigning love and obedience out of fear. Or "obey" out of a sycophantic desire for rewards and not out of genuine respect, love and gratitude. Similar to how people tend to slow down and drive exactly at the speed limit when they know a police car is driving behind them. Often times, the longer the police car drives behind them, the more anxious and resentful they become (with feelings of possible guilt rising up) because they suspect the police officer is "just LOOKING" (i.e. eager) to catch them in a violation.

Richard Swinburne said concerning the Hiddenness of God, that it's like being in a nursery. You don't hit your brother when you think your mother is there and watching. Rather, you hit your brother when you think she isn't there and watching. By partially veiling His existence, it provides an opportunity to make all the more free choices for God and goodness, or against God and for evil. God's hiddenness provides opportunity to develop and/or prove one's character. To develop virtues like compassion, courage, love, perseverance, patience, self-sacrifice, faith and trust in God. It provides opportunities for activities like evangelism, apologetics, discipleship, acts of charity and mercy (all of which God will reward). It provides opportunity for a truly willing devotion and commitment to God which angels can't demonstrate, prove or participate in to the degree humans can.  

So, in a sense the HoG (i.e. God's regulated epistemic distance) is a gift of God to man. A gift that has the potential for greater degrees of praise and (not to mention different kinds of) rewards for humans which angels cannot partake of. Angelic rewards will be different, but no less real. That's the paradoxical nature of both 1. the Hiddenness of God and 2. of the requirement of faith. On the one hand the HoG is an impoverishment, on the other hand it presents an opportunity for greater blessings. Similarly, in one sense faith is non-meritorous and is a means to magnify men's weakness and insufficiency to save themselves and conversely magnify God's sufficiency, grace and power to save. Yet, in another sense when Christians persevere in faith despite (and in opposition to) the presence of trials and obstacles, it affords a way for Christians to "graciously merit" greater rewards. Hence the paradoxical phrases used to describe this seemingly contradictory concept. John Piper used the phrase "conditional unmerited grace" in his book Future Grace.  John Gerstner was willing to use the phrase "works of super-erogation" in a Protestant sense in that good works (which are rooted in faith) can add to a Christian's rewards, even if it in no way contributes to his justification. Yes "gracious merit" is an oxymoron, but the concept was what Augustine was alluding to when he said that God crowns His own gifts when He rewards believers, since their ability to believe and do good deeds flow from God's own grace.

Back to the topic of the HoG.

In contrast to the fault finding trigger happy Policeman who is looking for any excuse to write up a ticket, the loving, forgiving and merciful heavenly Father, is "looking" for reasons to bless and reward people for the good they do. All things being equal that is; and not in a Pelagian or Semi-Pelagian way since orthodox Christianity denies both and opts for either Prevenient divinely initiated Grace as in Catholicism and Arminianism or Sufficient effectual Grace as in Calvinism [see my explanation of the differences in THIS blog].

Again, in such a world (where the knowledge of God's existence were coercive on earth) there would be sycophants who would obey God *merely* for the benefits rather than out of genuine love. But in both the cases of the anxious driver AND the "brown noser" [forgive the mental image], the problem wouldn't technically be the rationally coercive evidence of God's existence (since the saints in heaven have that and so have the unfallen angels from the time of their creation). Rather the attitude of the people involved will be what makes the difference. So, this would especially be true post lapsis (i.e. after the Fall) due (in part) to the natural depravity of men.

Still others, in such a world would respond to such irrefutable evidence in the opposite manner. They would, like Lucifer and his minions, rebel against God. As the saying goes, "Familiarity breeds contempt." J.P. Moreland has argued that after death humans will not have an opportunity to believe and repent because they will be exposed to such an abundance of rationally coercive proofs for the existence of God that it will no longer be the free kind of decision that those same humans had the opportunity of exercising before death. This might partially explain why the angels, as a species, were never given an opportunity for salvation. God may not have provided redemption for fallen angels because angelic sin was against way too much light. This means, because of redemption, the saints in heaven (i.e. saved humans) will relate to God on the basis of grace in a way that angels won't be able to. The "elect [unfallen] angels" never have their sins forgiven because they never sinned and (presumably) never will sin. Whereas saved human beings, will have greater reason to love God in heaven (not to mention now here on Earth) because, as the Lord Jesus said in Luke 7:47, "...he who is forgiven little, loves little." (cf. Luke 7:41-43). By implication, those who are forgiven greatly, can love greatly. Christians who have experienced the grace and love of God that non-Christians haven't experienced sin against greater light and love and therefore ought to love God that much more greatly.

Again, I suspect part of the reason why God has providentially made His existence partly vague the way He has is so that there would be opportunity for people to willingly/freely (not necessarily libertarianly) seek, find, choose, and love God. God isn't merely interested in humans merely coming to believe THAT God exists. That's relatively unimportant to God. God wants humans to believe IN Him in the sense of of having a personal loving and trusting relationship with them that results in 1. the greater eventual manifestation of His glory and 2. greater remunerative (gracious) rewards partly in this life and ultimately in the afterlife. Constant rationally coercive evidences in this life would be a hindrance to that (to some extent as it was to the angels).

God has ordained the amount and limitation of knowledge for both angels and humans in the differing (and contrasting) ways He has in order to:

1. prove through His differing creatures that He Himself is truly worthy of such love and devotion from both those who do have such undeniable evidence (like the angels who didn't fall) and from those who don't have such evidence like fallen human beings on earth.

2. provide opportunity for greater reward for His human believers who persevere in faith, obedience and faithfulness even when there are times when God's existence is in doubt; or when while His existence is believed, yet His seeming indifference seems to be more the case. Since, as C.S. Lewis said, there is a kind of faith (or faithfulness) that believes and perseveres despite adversity (including challenges to belief in God's existence and/or trust in God's goodness).

In a time of doubt C.S. Lewis wrote in his A Grief Observed, "The conclusion I dread is not 'So there's no God after all,' but 'So this is what God's really like. Deceive yourself no longer..' "

Catholic saint (or not-so-saint) Theresa of Avila accordingly said, after being bucked off a horse and into a muddy puddle or river, "[God,] If this is how you treat your friends, no wonder you have so few."

In times of trials, sufferings and deprivations there is the special opportunity to believe God's promises that to those who love, believe and trust in Him, and believe He also loves them, He will compensate and console them for it all in the next life (if not also to some degree in this life).

It takes a special (as a Calvinist, I would argue a God given) persevering faith to believe "behind a frowning providence, He hides a smiling face," as the hymn God Moves In A Mysterious Way states.  Nevertheless, the experience of Christians down the centuries also shows that Charles G. Trumbull wasn't being too hyperbolic when he said, "Those who are readiest to trust God without other evidence than His Word always receive the greatest number of visible evidences of His love." That's not necessarily true in this world. But ultimately it will be true in the next for the Christian.

Martin Luther wrote, "But surely it is preferable to lose the world rather than God the Creator of the world, who is able to create innumerable worlds afresh, and who is [Himself] better than infinite worlds! For what comparison is there between things temporal and things eternal?" Not just anyone can believe what Luther wrote in a way that doesn't make God a means to an end, rather than an end in Himself.

All the above things mentioned gets to the issue of where such faith (and faithfulness) and love can come from with the amount of evidence 1. "for" 2. "against" and 3. "neutral on" God's existence. For the most part, most of what I have already said could be affirmed by both Arminian-like and Calvinistic-like Christians. I encourage my Arminian-like fellow Christians to avail themselves of the arguments I've so far mentioned. However, this is where we must part ways. As a Calvinist, I believe the human faith to savingly believe in, love and trust God are all ultimately the gifts of God that flow from His Sovereign Grace. That is to say, as a Calvinist I believe in predestination. That God elects some to salvation while passing over others through non-election.

In light of my Calvinism, these further quotes from Pascal's Pensées are also useful for the various high predestinarian point of views.

577 There is sufficient clearness to enlighten the elect, and sufficient obscurity to humble them. There is sufficient obscurity to blind the reprobate, and sufficient clearness to condemn them, and make them inexcusable.—Saint Augustine, Montaigne, Sébond.

574 All things work together for good to the elect, even the obscurities of Scripture; for they honour them because of what is divinely clear. And all things work together for evil to the rest of the world, even what is clear; for they revile such, because of the obscurities which they do not understand.

562 It will be one of the confusions of the damned to see that they are condemned by their own reason, by which they claimed to condemn the Christian religion.

576 God has made the blindness of this people subservient to the good of the elect.

Blaise Pascal, being Roman Catholic, wrote these things as someone who, while rejecting Jansenism as heresy, nevertheless held to a high view of predestinating sovereign grace. Evidently, he was influenced by the Jansenists whom he was exposed to in his youth and attempted to hold to an Augustinian view permissible under Catholicism.

Some will argue that these comments and answers regarding the HoG won't satisfy the requests for reasons, evidences and arguments that non-believers may have in order to believe in Christianity and trust in Christ. It wasn't a purpose of this particular blog to provide positive evidence for the truth of Christianity. My other blogs present such evidences and arguments as well as providing links to other resources. [Here's a LINK to my blog on the the issue of the sufficiency or insufficiency of the evidence for Christianity.]

But even if this particular blog did provide positive evidence, we Calvinists heartily agree that non-Christians, if they remain unregenerate, will never be satisfied with the sufficient evidence. Since they will be judging by the criteria of their unbelieving, arbitrary, inconsistent, and question begging standards. "Standards" which they use to examine and judge what are often strawmen representations of Christianity. We believe that apart from the grace of God, they will do this by suppressing the evidence for God's existence due to their sinful depraved nature (which we were all born with).


When Desiderius Erasmus fully realized the implications of Martin Luther's doctrine of predestination, Erasmus (essentially) asked, "If predestination is true, who can come to believe that God actually loves them personally? Or who can bring themselves to love such a God?" (paraphrase). Luther's answer was, "I reply, Nobody! Nobody can! But the elect shall believe it; and the rest shall perish without believing it, raging and blaspheming, as you [Erasmus] describe them. So there will be some who believe it."

That's because it takes God given faith to believe that God is truly good even when there seemingly appears to be evidence to the contrary both in the world and in the Word (i.e. in truly Biblical doctrines like that of God's sovereignty). Nevertheless, the persevering Christian's experience bears out the reality of God's goodness. As Psalm 73 declares.

1. Truly God is good to Israel,
to those who are pure in heart.
2 But as for me, my feet had almost stumbled,
my steps had nearly slipped.
3 For I was envious of the arrogant
when I saw the prosperity of the wicked....

16 But when I thought how to understand this,
it seemed to me a wearisome task,
17 until I went into the sanctuary of God;
then I discerned their end....

21 When my soul was embittered,
when I was pricked in heart,
22 I was brutish and ignorant;
I was like a beast toward you.

23 Nevertheless, I am continually with you;
you hold my right hand.
24 You guide me with your counsel,
and afterward you will receive me to glory.

In his book The Bondage of the Will Martin Luther wrote:

Keep in view three lights: the light of nature, the light of grace, and the light of glory (this is a common and a good distinction). By the light of nature, it is inexplicable that it should be just for the good to be afflicted and the bad to prosper; but the light of grace explains it. By the light of grace, it is inexplicable how God can damn him who by his own strength can do nothing but sin and become guilty. Both the light of nature and the light of grace here insist that the fault lies not in the wretchedness of man, but in the injustice of God; nor can they judge otherwise of a God who crowns the ungodly freely, without merit, and does not crown, but damns another, who is perhaps less, and certainly not more, ungodly. But the light of glory insists otherwise, and will one day reveal God, to whom alone belongs a judgment whose justice is incomprehensible, as a God Whose justice is most righteous and evident - provided only that in the meanwhile we believe it, as we are instructed and encouraged to do by the example of the light of grace explaining what was a puzzle of the same order to the light of nature.

Lastly, another response to the atheistic argument for the non-existence of God based on the hiddenness of God and/or the insufficiency of the evidence is the Calvinistic belief that God doesn't intend to save all human beings. The assumption of most standard arguments against God's existence based on the hiddenness of God and/or the vagueness of the evidence for God's existence is the false premise that God has the benevolent desire to save every human being equally. Based on that false premise atheists argue that therefore God would provide ample evidence of His existence. Since God hasn't provided such evidence (to their satisfaction and their definition of "ample" and "sufficient"), God therefore doesn't exist. While some Calvinists believe that God has no benevolent intentions and/or salvific desires for the non-elect, other Calvinists do believe that in some sense God is benevolent (not merely beneficent) toward the non-elect, and may even desire their salvation in some lesser sense. Regardless of which Calvinistic view one holds, it denies the false atheistic premise. And as I said above and elsewhere, the evidence can be sufficient without it being coercive.


Footnote:
It may seem to some that my solution is contradictory in that on the one hand, as a Calvinist, I deny libertarian free will; yet on the other hand argue that the reason why God has regulated the evidence for His existence in the proportions He has (pros and cons)  is to preserve our willing choices so that they can be rewarded or punished. Even Christians who are not Calvinists have critiqued Calvinism on this point since it seems self-evident that both praiseworthiness and blameworthiness depend on libertarian free will. However, Calvinists do affirm and have philosophical arguments in defense of the possibility, reality and appropriateness of merit and demerit.

See for example, Paul Manata's book Free Will, Moral Responsibility, and Reformed Theology: A Contemporary Introduction


******************************************************

In the future, I'll be adding relevant links below. Here are some preliminary links:

The Hiddenness of God article at the Ravi Zacharias International Ministries website


Why doesn’t God give us more evidence of his existence? by Wintery Knight


https://youtu.be/d8EZBX8ZbWQ
Divine Hiddenness of God by William Lane Craig




https://youtu.be/7-pXilhksQA
Divine Hiddenness of God by Douglas Geivett



Related blogs of mine:

Detecting and Finding God
gospelcrumbs.blogspot.com/2013/07/detecting-and-finding-god.html

Christian Apologetics: Who Needs it? by William Lane Craig  

Book Reviews of Recent Atheist Authors by Christian Apologists

Evidence and Arguments Against Materialism and Naturalism

Answering Moral Objections to the Bible

Could God Command a Christian to Kill?

Resources for Dealing with Alleged Bible Contradictions, Discrepancies and Errors

Dealing with Christian Doubts

A Rational, Pragmatic and Prudential Argument for Believing in God 


At the present time I strongly lean toward supralapsarianism. Here's a link to a blog regarding whether reprobation is conditional, unconditional or both. It's touches on the justice or injustice of reprobation.
http://misclane.blogspot.com/2013/05/reprobation-conditional-or-unconditional.html

More relevant Pascal Quotes

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Trinitarianism and Judaism

or " Trinitarianism - Binitarianism - Unitarianism Contact! "
(an allusion to an old TV show)


On another blog, I posted some Resources in Defense of Trinitarianism. Included in the post are some preliminary quotations which I want to reproduce here.


Christian (and Jewish Messianic Believer in Jesus) Dr. Michael L. Brown, wrote

Interestingly, Dr. Benjamin Sommer, a professor in Bible and ancient Near Eastern languages at the Jewish Theological Seminary (that’s right, the Jewish Theological Seminary), came to similar conclusions in his recent book, The Bodies of God. He wrote: “Some Jews regard Christianity’s claim to be a monotheistic religion with grave suspicion, both because of the doctrine of the trinity (how can three equal one?) and because of Christianity’s core belief that God took bodily form. . . . No Jew sensitive to Judaism’s own classical sources, however, can fault the theological model Christianity employs when it avows belief in a God who has an earthly body as well as a Holy Spirit and a heavenly manifestation, for that model, we have seen, is a perfectly Jewish one. A religion whose scripture contains the fluidity traditions [referring to God appearing in bodily form in the Tanakh], whose teachings emphasize the multiplicity of the shekhinah, and whose thinkers speak of the sephirot does not differ in its theological essentials from a religion that adores the triune God.”
So, it appears that there are Jewish scholars who do not believe in Yeshua who can see what my dear friend Rabbi Blumenthal cannot. Let’s continue to pray for Rabbi Blumenthal!

In a book review of Dr. Sommer's book The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel 
someone named J. Todd Hibbard, (University of Tennessee at Chattanooga) acknowledges that Dr. Sommer believes the Christian conception of the Trinity is not incompatible with various traditions within Judaism. It doesn't matter if Hibbard is a Christian or not. I quote him only to further corroborate Dr. Brown's interpretation of Dr. Sommer.

The final chapter finds Sommer donning his theologian hat in order to answer the question, “What do the Hebrew Bible's fluidity traditions teach a modern religious Jew?” (p. 126). After noting that the antifluidity traditions in P and D dominate the final form of the Hebrew Bible, he notes that fluidity traditions found elsewhere (notably in JE) are still present. He briefly explores the development of these traditions in the postbiblical rabbinic literature, the kabbalah and early Christianity. With respect to the latter, Sommer insists that core Christian assertions—the trinity and incarnation—are not theologically impermissible within the world of Judaism, but rather are faithful to the fluidity model of divinity found in ancient Israel. For modern Jews, Sommer demonstrates how biblical notions of fluidity and antifluidity pose challenges for both liberal and conservative Jews, though not in the same way. He concludes by insisting that, contrary to customary positions, it is the fluidity model that offers the strongest statement of monotheism consistent with the personhood of God.


In another book review, Esther J Hamori says the following:


In chapter 6, Sommer traces the fluidity model into later Judaism and Christianity. He points to the continuation of these concepts—the fluidity of the divine self and multiplicity of embodiment, the rejection of these notions, and various implications for sacred space—in rabbinic literature and kabbalah, addressing what this all might mean for those reading the Hebrew Bible as scripture today. He then frames the concept of incarnation in the New Testament in terms of the fluidity model and discusses the impact this has had on later Christianity. It is fascinating to see some of this unfold, for instance, as he traces the ways in which Protestantism and Catholicism prioritize different  voices among the fluidity and antifluidity traditions. One of his laudable goals here is to demonstrate ways in which much of Christian theology is not so foreign to Judaism. He concludes, “No Jew sensitive to Judaism’s own classical sources, however, can fault the theological model Christianity employs when it avows belief in a God who has an earthly body as well as a Holy Spirit and a heavenly manifestation, for that model, we have seen, is a perfectly Jewish one. A religion whose scriptures contains the fluidity traditions, whose teachings emphasize the multiplicity of the shekhinah, and whose thinkers speak of the sephirot does not differ in its theological essentials from a religion that adores a triune God” (135). The similarities of the Christian concept of the simultaneous presence of God in heaven and God on earth to the older fluidity model are striking, and it will be fruitful to consider Christian theology in light of this. At the same time, there are also important differences between these types of embodiment, and at a certain point the similarity may be a bit overdrawn. Sommer’s view does not take into account the difference between theophany and incarnation, between temporary manifestation and full human identity and life, as claimed in Christian theology. Perhaps more significantly, while the concept of the Trinity may be seen to reflect the multiplicity of embodiment as in the older fluidity traditions, it does not seem particularly fluid. Finally, Sommer concludes that this fluidity in Judaism and Christianity allows God both immanence and transcendence, and that it shows that the divine is not bound to any one place. (Or, as I have argued in regard to some biblical texts, even the embodiment of God demonstrates divine freedom, rather than limitation.)


Here's an almost perfect video on the plurality of persons in the Godhead in the Old Testament. Unfortunately the narrator slips up four times. Instead of using the word "being" or "beings", I would have used the word "person" or "persons" in the following locations. I am assuming Latin Trinitarianism in this correction. By using the word "being(s)" something like tritheism or social trinitarianism would be implied. Whereas the use of the word "person(s)" would be less biased and be open to either a Latin trinitarian OR tritheistic interpretation pending further Scriptural and logical considerations. Here are the four locations.

#1 "...and yet distinct from another divine BEING who is also God." (at 4:35).
#2 "...this divine figure is also distinct from another divine BEING who is also God..." (at 4:58)
#3 "...and yet distinct from another divine BEING..." (at 8:25)
#4 "...Three separate divine BEINGS, who are all God." (at 12:46)


 

At one his websites (Two Powers in Heaven) Dr. Michael Heiser continues to argue rabbinical scholar Alan Segal's claim (nearly 30 years ago) that up until the 2nd century C.E., it was permissible in Judaism to believe in the concept of there being "two powers" in heaven without being considered heretical or pagan or polytheistic. It was a sort of Jewish Binitarianism. In the following video lecture, Dr. Heiser makes his case succinctly. Then using ancient Jewish Binitarianism he bridges the gap from (strict/monistic) Monotheism to Trinitarianism.





Clearly, it is NOT a foregone conclusion that the Old Testament and ancient Jews specifically taught strict monistic unipersonal monotheism.

Again, for more information checkout my blog post Resources in Defense of Trinitarianism

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Dealing with Christian Doubts

or "Till Doubt Do Us Part?"



Reading C. Michael Patton's article The Miserable Christian Doubt has reminded me how common it is for Christians to have periods of doubt. So, I decided to dedicate this blog post to providing resources for Christians who are dealing with doubt and spiritual depression (which are related). Start with reading Patton's article.

I'll continue adding links and information as I come across useful resources. 

Dealing with doubt is something Christians often feel uncomfortable discussing or admitting to because it can have a stigma attached to it. Doubting Christians can be looked down upon by fellow Christians as being spiritually inferior or being "in [some particular] sin(s)". Ironically, sometimes those very Christians looking down on doubters do so precisely because they themselves have doubts and are fearful of doubting even more (whether they are consciously aware of it or not). Doubting Christians can often be treated as if they had the plague. Fellow Christians sometimes avoid them and try to keep their distance lest they be infected too. Even though, the very things doubting Christians need are the love, compassion, support, counsel and prayers of currently doubt free Christians. Doubting Christians can feel not only condemned by others but by themselves. The overt or subtle accusation (demonically reinforced) is, "If you were just spiritually mature and faithful enough you wouldn't be going through this period of doubt." For example, if they had read the Bible enough or prayed enough.

Moreover, spiritual pride can lead people to want to hide and deny their doubts because they don't want others looking down on them, or because they want to maintain their reputation for being a "spiritual giant" (cf. 1 Cor 10:13ff). All the while justifying their hiding it because if they let it be known that they were doubting, it would lead others to doubt as well (and they don't want to "stumble their brother"). However, hiding it and suppressing it can eventually lead to a person feeling like a hypocrite and as intellectually dishonest; and thus sometimes leading to apostasy (as if apostasy were "the only honest or rational thing to do"). As Patton has said, (paraphrasing) "Everyone (i.e. Christians) has doubted their faith. If they haven't, they are either lying OR THEY DON'T TAKE THEIR FAITH SERIOUSLY."

Doubters who HAVE been serious about their faith can look to others who claim to not doubt and conclude that those others aren't intellectually honest and earnest enough to be willing to get the bottom of the issues (i.e. of getting to the truth). That those who never have doubts are neither honest about the facts or honest with themselves. While there might be some truth to this, it's also true that these doubters can enter a period of intellectual pride. That in turn can lead to the conclusion that only anti-intellectuals can believe such things and so eventually can lead to apostasy. This kind of intellectual pride can develop because they look at themselves and recognize that they are willing to do the research that simpler Christians aren't willing or able to do (for lack of time, financial resources, or intellectual ability/aptitude etc.). Such prideful doubters begin to look on simple Christians as "sheeple" ((a portmanteau of "sheep" and "people") and so naturally want to avoid the stigma of being an ignorant religious simpleton. The research and study now becomes a matter of pride rather than a search for and faithfulness to the truth [and to HIM who is the Truth]. Stephen Charnock wrote, "Unbelief was the first sin, and pride was the first-born of it". Unbelief and pride can re-enforce each other in a vicious circle leading to apostasy.

However, not all doubters are or become prideful. Some are sincerely and humbly seeking the truth. But they often do so thinking they need to have an answer to every apologetical question, objection and challenge if they are going to have intellectual, moral, and epistemological integrity/honesty.

As a Vantillian presuppositionalist, I believe that all of creation testifies to the existence of God such that everyone is without excuse for believing in God and knowing they are accountable to Him. However, I don't believe God set up creation so that belief in Him is rationally coercive (even if it's existentially so). See this blog. Therefore, doubters need to realize a few things which may not have previously entered their minds. Here are just some helpful suggestions.

- Realize that "Absence of evidence, is not evidence of absence". (taken from William Lane Craig)

- "Realize that the presence of other possibilities does not necessarily equate to the presence of other probabilities." (taken from Patton's article). Just because there are logical alternative possibilities doesn't mean that they are equally probable or plausible [or even desirable].

-"Focus only on the issues that make or break Christianity." (taken from Patton's article). Not everything one believes is essential to Christianity. For example, don't lose your faith in Christ because you may have recently discovered that a certain eschatological position is not as Biblically supported as you once thought.

-Don’t think you can ever be an expert in everything. (taken from Patton's article). The truth is that both you and the people you read, listen to or speak with (whether Christian OR NON-CHRISTIAN) are limited finite creatures who themselves don't know all there is to know about any topic even if they supposedly are an "expert" on the topic.

- Patton recommends taking a break from apologetics. This is something I heartily agree with if your doubts were brought on by "doing" apologetics. Sometimes we're so busy "doing Christian" things, that we forget to be busy "BEING Christian". There's a quote from C.S. Lewis that's relevant. I  have two version I got online and I'm not sure which one is more accurate. But here they are.



“A man can’t be always defending the truth; there must be a time to feed on it” - C.S. Lewis (from Lewis' Reflections on the Psalms)

Sometimes as Christians, out of love for the Lord, our zeal leads us to become more works oriented than fellowship oriented. Fellowship with God and others. That's the mistake Martha fell into and to which we're all prone.

Luke 10:38    Now it happened as they went that He entered a certain village; and a certain woman named Martha welcomed Him into her house.39 And she had a sister called Mary, who also sat at Jesus' feet and heard His word.40 But Martha was distracted with much serving, and she approached Him and said, "Lord, do You not care that my sister has left me to serve alone? Therefore tell her to help me."
41    And Jesus answered and said to her, "Martha, Martha, you are worried and troubled about many things.42 But one thing is needed, and Mary has chosen that good part, which will not be taken away from her."

While some people begin to have doubts because they have been overwhelmed by apologetical issues, some people persist in doubt partly because they refuse to engage their minds on apologetical issues (the opposite problem). Here are two links to two videos by William Lane Craig where he shows that while Christian apologetics isn't absolutely necessary, it is VERY USEFUL  in bringing people to faith and helping preserve their faith. It's especially useful in inoculating children and teens against the onslaught of unbelief and objections to their faith they will inevitably encounter in school and academia. I've re-posted these links a second time later in the blog where the rest of the links are gathered.



-Even if the evidence for and against Christianity were completely equal [which I deny], it doesn't mean that they are equally desirable. For example, if you compared Christianity with atheism, you should stick with Christianity since atheism by necessity (and by the admission of many prominent atheists) is a losing bet. Atheism, if rightly understood is futile and futility is futile. See also Craig on Pascal's Wager

-Be honest with God in prayer about your doubts. God can handle your doubts. Yes, doubting as a Christian is sin, but God can handle it. God is not surprised by doubt. Or even by YOUR doubts. In fact, God often uses seasons of doubt in the lives of Christians to eventually strengthen their faith. Often people who start doubting think they need to stop praying in order to maintain objectivity while they search for the truth about Christianity themselves. But that assumes that you can come to know or be confirmed in the knowledge of the truth of Christianity apart from God's Holy Spirit (which the Bible denies cf. 1 Cor. 2:14; John 3:27; Matt. 16:17; Heb. 12:2).

-Realize that your reasons for personally believing don't have to be the reasons why others should believe. In fact, in their totality, they can't because your Christian experience can't be reproduced. It's as individual as God's providence intended. Realize the truth of Christianity doesn't depend on your ability to either successfully defend the truth of Christianity OR your ability to successfully persuade others to believe it. Make the following distinctions.

1. the reasons for your personally believing your Christian beliefs (i.e. reasons for believing they are true or why you accept them). These can include rational, existential, emotional, prudential, supernatural, and miraculous reasons. They can also include examples of answered prayer, healing, providential coincidences (et cetera). Often these can include pre-reflective reasons as well. People are deep pools and just because people might, through introspection, come to the fresh realization that they believed something for more than rational reasons doesn't necessitate that what they have believed or embraced in the past is actually false; or that it's incumbent on them to have a rational basis for all their beliefs [such evidentialism is impossible to satisfy because it leads to an infinite regress].
2. the causes for your beliefs. This can include your culture, upbringing, education (etc.). You may not be a Calvinist, but from a Calvinistic perspective, God is the ultimate cause of your saving faith. Remember that just because you may have been influenced (even "indoctrinated") to believe in Christianity doesn't necessitate it's false. EVERYONE has been indoctrinated to some belief system to some degree or another; and if Christianity is true, then spiritual neutrality is impossible [see the literature on the "myth of neutrality" by writers on presuppositional apologetics].
3. your existential defense of and justification for your beliefs (which, like #1, can include supernatural and miraculous reasons, answered prayer, healing, providential coincidences etc.). Realize that Christians who experience God cannot convey in words or existentially share with non-Christians that kind of self-authenticating God given experience. Nevertheless, such a defense can lead people to consider the truth of Christianity and can (and should) prop up Christians whenever they begin to have doubts. See for example J.P. Moreland's testimony of supernatural experiences HERE (starting at 13 minutes).By God's grace, the kind of experiences Moreland has had,  and the kind you may have had, if perceived correctly can inoculate you from naturalism and materialism. Here's another link to J.P. Moreland on the subject of God's Silence. HERE.
4. your rational defense and justification for the truthfulness of your beliefs (which may or may not satisfy others, but does your own epistemological senses). That is, your case for why you're justified and warranted in believing as you do. This ought to be post-reflective. This is not the same as the above since the former includes reasons for belief that go beyond truth and falsity. Remember that just because you may not be able to answer every objection or win every argument doesn't mean that Christianity is false. Since non-persuasive (even "bad") arguments can be made for true propositions, just as persuasive arguments can be made for false propositions.

5. your case TO OTHERS for the truthfulness of your beliefs and why THEY should believe it as being true as well (i.e. apologetics proper, which is person relative). This is not exactly the same as the above since not everyone will accept the premises you might use in the arguments you formulate according to #4. For example, you'll have difficulty using empirical evidence and data to convince an empirical skeptic.
6. your case for why others should embrace/welcome/accept your beliefs (i.e. part of evangelism proper, which is person relative). This is different from the above because just because you can convince someone that something is true, doesn't necessarily mean that they will want to embrace it for themselves.


-Realize that if Christianity is true, then one doesn't need to have answers for every conceivable objection since it would be contrary to what Scripture teaches for some Christians at one time and place to have necessary (key word) reasons for belief which other Christians didn't have or didn't have access to. As William Lane Craig has pointed out, apologetics while extremely useful, isn't absolutely necessary since people ought to (and only do) accept the truth of Christianity (ultimately) on account of the inner testimony of the Holy Spirit. See, the following videos by William Lane Craig on doubt.

-Realize that if Christianity is true, then your doubting is a spiritual issue and that there are demons who are seeking your eternal spiritual destruction. If demons exist, they don't "fight fair". They will kick you while you're down. You might need to clear the spiritual air by doing spiritual warfare. You will need fellow Christians praying for you. It WOULDN'T HURT if Christianity is false. But it WOULD HELP if Christianity is true. Additionally, the evidence for malevolent spirits from your own personal experience and the testimony of others (both Christian and non-Christian) suggests the reality not only of the spiritual realm, but also of the possibility of the existence of benevolent spirits (e.g. angels). By extension, the evidence for both malevolent and benevolent immaterial personal entities suggest the possibility of a supremely good spirit, namely God. See THIS LINK to testimonies of demonic and angelic experiences.

-Read Christian biographies like that of George Muller/Mueller. Christian biographies take you out of your current world and its unique advantages, disadvantages and problems and immerses you in another one. Sometimes in order to see things as they really are we need a different perspective. Biographies acquaint us with God's providential faithfulness throughout Church history and gives us a broader view of the stakes involved in you acceptance or rejection of the Christian worldview.

I recommend starting with George Muller: Man of Faith and Miracles (Men of Faith series) by Basil Miller
amazon.com link HERE

Here's a link to public domain copies of George Müller of Bristol by Arthur T. Pierson
http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/26522

Love the Lord With Heart and Mind by Steve Hays and James Anderson is a collection of answers by contemporary Christian intellectuals to a questionnaire Steve Hays sent them on the topics of their conversion and continued belief. http://calvindude.com/ebooks/Love-the-Lord-with-Heart-and-Mind.pdf

 ********************************************

 Dealing with Doubts

William Lane Craig on Dealing with Doubt
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYq-xNpokEs&feature=share&list=PL3gdeV4Rk9Ed60n4NhBv8q1iTvB1LW_dC


Dealing With Doubt (Q & A #251) by William Lane Craig
http://www.reasonablefaith.org/dealing-with-doubt1

John Piper on how to deal with doubting God's existence
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBPoF5nxdRA

John Piper on how to deal with doubting your own devotion to Christ
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oD2O13CIb6U

John Piper - Battling Unbelief: Bank On His Faithfulness, Not Your Fickleness
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1nDows1nMqk


What do I do if I've tried to believe in Jesus but can't?
http://youtu.be/skOJMUYhgQ8


John Piper asked whether he has ever questioned the sincerity of his devotion to Christ
http://youtu.be/fhWHrbUcdAo


Dealing with Doubts? With Mike Licona https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVZnRx5lBcc 

Christian Apologetics: Who Needs It? - William Lane Craig
http://youtu.be/KDH-_4vkKUk

When God is Silent by J.P. Moreland
http://youtu.be/Hx6fOnMKkJk   I also HIGHLY recommend the following message

 Discerning God's Voice by J.P. Moreland
http://youtu.be/Da-WMdu3qd4

Eight Points Of Encouragement For Those Who Are Doubting Their Faith by C. Michael Patton
www.reclaimingthemind.org/blog/2011/11/eight-points-of-encouragement-for-those-who-are-doubting-their-faith/

Dealing With Doubt by C. Michael Patton Part ONE, Part TWO, Part THREE

John the Baptist, Doubt, and My Three Days As An Atheist by C. Michael Patton 
www.reclaimingthemind.org/blog/2012/08/john-the-baptist-doubt-and-my-three-days-as-an-atheist/

Eight Issues That Do Not Make or Break Christianity by C. Michael Patton
http://www.reclaimingthemind.org/blog/2013/03/eight-issues-that-do-not-make-or-break-christianity/

Seven Reasons Why Christians Doubt
http://www.reclaimingthemind.org/blog/2014/05/seven-reasons-why-christians-doubt/


C. Michael Patton asked some Evangelicals to write on the topic of doubt. Here are some of them.

Michael Licona on Doubt
Paul Copan on Doubt
Darrell Bock on Doubt
Gary Habermas on Doubt

Here are more links to resources on doubt by Gary Habermas:

Dealing with Doubt with Gary Habermas (29 min. video) http://youtu.be/jVwq6pdZL-M

Emotional Doubt Innoculation with Gary Habermas (1 hour and 20 minute video) http://youtu.be/waLKa0BLvBQ

Dealing With Doubt by Gary Habermas
http://www.garyhabermas.com/books/dealing_with_doubt/dealing_with_doubt.htm
[ENTIRE BOOK FREELY ONLINE]

The Thomas Factor: Using Your Doubts to Draw Closer to God by Gary Habermas
http://www.garyhabermas.com/books/thomas_factor/thomas_factor.htm
[ENTIRE BOOK FREELY ONLINE]

Factual Doubt - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/K02r2zw1pk8

Factual Doubt Q & A - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/CH2auev20Vw

Emotional Doubt - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/ibQIKbZwkmQ

Emotional Doubt
http://youtu.be/v_a_3pW2ocI

Volitional Doubt - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/jq7by00GwjA

Volitional Doubt Q&A - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/jXRktcTBwqs

Silence of God - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/1svIPRtpXUk

Silence of God Q&A - Gary Habermas, PhD
http://youtu.be/2ky-p7fIl1I

What are some common myths about doubt? with Gary Habermas (3 min. video) http://youtu.be/XbXLwqZ4R2c 

What is the best way to deal with factual doubt? with Gary Habermas (3 min. video) http://youtu.be/xlkQ_gsCgIs

What are the different kinds of doubts that someone can have? with Gary Habermas (6 min. video) http://youtu.be/Ks1epLdbYtI

Godly people who have struggled with doubt in their life? with Gary Habermas (3 min. video) http://youtu.be/4Ss_jqYGpXw

Will more facts help someone who suffers from emotional doubts? with Gary Habermas (7 min. video) http://youtu.be/ta3ognYXutQ

What can you say to someone who says, "I just can't believe...What's wrong with me?" with Gary Habermas (4 min. video) http://youtu.be/E6QhkJ9YlNE

What can you say to someone whose faith is shaken? with Gary Habermas (3 min. video) http://youtu.be/11I_A44y958

Why is a person's will so important in the area of doubt? with Gary Habermas (4 min. video) http://youtu.be/WXCg7Ut5-us


While some people begin to have doubts because they have been overwhelmed by apologetical issues, some people persist in doubt partly because they refuse to engage their minds on apologetical issues (the opposite problem). Here are two links to two videos by William Lane Craig where he shows that while Christian apologetics isn't absolutely necessary, it is VERY USEFUL in bringing people to faith and helping preserve their faith. It's especially useful in inoculating children and teens against the onslaught of unbelief and objections to their faith they will inevitably encounter in school and academia.






I also HIGHLY recommend the apologetical posts at Triablogue. Do searches on whatever topics you're interested in or are struggling with. Go to www.google.com/advanced_search and type in "triablogue.blogspot.com" in the "site or domain:" field. Don't type "www.triablogue.blogspot.com"

Here are samples of Triablogue posts dealing with doubts.

Doubting Thomas
Doubting and self-doubting
Count your blessings
When In Doubt
They that wait upon the Lord
On a wing and a prayer

It goes without saying that I recommend my other blog posts alongside this one. For example my blog post Resources for Dealing with Alleged Bible Contradictions, Discrepancies and Errors



Spiritual Depression

Sermons by Sam Waldron (two of which I believe may be the same sermon preached at different times):
Elijah's Death Wish
Elijah's Struggle with Carnal Fear

When the Brook Dries Up

Elijah Beside the Dry Brook

Spiritual Depression by
D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones is extremely helpful (amazon.com link).
 

A Divine Cordial by Thomas Watson
 




********************************************

Spiritual Warfare


Precious Remedies Against Satan's Devices by Thomas Brooks


The Adversary: The Christian Versus Demon Activity by Mark Bubeck (amazon.com link)






While I'm still writing this blog, I might as well post it now since it'll never be "finished." That's because I'll continue to add links indefinitely.



Saturday, March 2, 2013

The Heart of God Affected by Prayer by Edward D. Griffin

Sermon XXVI [sermon 26] 

THE HEART OF GOD AFFECTED BY PRAYER

by Edward D. Griffin

Gen. XXXII. 28. [Genesis 32:28]

And he said, Thy name shall be called no more Jacob but Israel; for as a prince hast thou power with God and with men, and has prevailed.

Jacob, having taken certain extraordinary measures to wrest the birthright and blessing from Esau, was compelled by his brother's hate to flee to Padanaram. In this country, which lay to the east of Euphrates, lived Laban, the brother of Jacob's mother. The wanderer took up his abode with his uncle, married his two daughters, and by them had a numerous offspring. After the lapse of twenty years God commanded him to return to his father, and renewed the promise of his protection. Jacob set out on his return, crossed Euphrates and came to Mahanaim, a place on the east of Jordan, which afterwards belonged to the tribe of Gad. From this place, or about this time, he sent messengers before him to Mount Seir, (a country on the south of Canaan, in which Esau had settled,) to make his peace with his brother. The messengers returned with the account that Esau was on his way with four hundred armed men. Jacob had now crossed the river Jabbok and had proceeded on his way as far as Jordan. At this intelligence he was greatly alarmed. For notwithstanding the general promises of God, he knew not what particular trials might await him. Though his own life was safe, he knew not how many of his children were doomed to bleed on his brother's sword. It was a trying moment. Something more was to be done than to sit still and pray. Notwithstanding all the promises and all his trust in God, he knew that means must be used for the preservation of his family: and the means which he adopted discovered a remarkable sagacity and knowledge of the human heart. He set apart five droves of cattle as a present, which he sent across Jordan to meet his brother. He separated the cattle into different droves, and sent one drove after another, with suitable distances between; wisely foreseeing that, coming in this order, they would make a deeper impression on his brother than though they had all met him at once.

In the mean time he decamps in the night and carries back his family several miles up Jabbok, to the ford of the river. There he crosses it and leaves his family on the north side, in a place of as great safety as he could find. This done, he re-crosses the ford, takes his station between his family and the approaching enemy,—on a spot of ground which from the vision of that night was afterwards called Penuel,—and then casts himself on God.

This was indeed a solemn and most trying hour. It was the dead of night. Universal stillness reigned. His sleeepless family lay trembling on the other side of Jabbok. His brother was hastening forward, with forced marches and implacable resentments, to slay "the mother with the children." To flee, thus encumbered with women and children, was impossible. To attempt resistance against so great a force, would be vain. What can screen him from a brother's fury? He has exhausted all the means in his power. He can do no more.— What hopes then remain but those which rely on heaven? To heaven he turned his eyes. Soon a bright form appeared before him. It was the same that had appeared to him at Bethel; the same Person, and perhaps the same figure, that afterwards hung on Calvary.

By miraculous light he was emboldened to embrace him and to press him importunately for a blessing. The heavenly form put on the appearance of resistance, as though he would tear himself away. How could he be spared? What could the patriarch do alone in that trembling crisis? Methinks I hear the cries of the affrighted children from the other side, and the fierce tread of hostile feet before. He could not let him go. He was emboldened, (surprising confidence!) to hold the vision fast. O did he know what he had in his embrace? It was nothing less than the treasure of the universe. How could he let him go? Who would not give his life for such another embrace?

This surprising struggle, which was designed to bring out God's condescension to be wrestled with in prayer, and the confidence and efficacy of faith, continued "until the breaking of the day." Then said the Angel of the covenant "Let me go for the day breaketh. And he said, I will not let thee go except thou bless me. And he said unto him, what is thy name? And he said, Jacob. And he said, Thy name shall be called no more Jacob but Israel; for as a prince hast thou power with God and with men, and hast prevailed.—And he blessed him there."

Having thus prevailed with God, and obtained power to prevail with men, that is, with Esau and his host, his heart was at rest.

The sun arose as he passed over to his family. He had not been there long before, across the plain, he discovered his brother, approaching. He had just time to dispose his family in the order in which he wished them to approach;—the two handmaids with their children first, Leah with her children next, and the beloved Rachel with her Joseph in the rear; in order that the most beloved might be the least exposed in case of attack, or in case of peace that the most beautiful, by coming last, might complete the agreeable impression. With all his confidence in God he still adhered to means.

Before the whole Jacob himself passed over, to receive the blessing on the very spot where he had wrestled with the Angel. "And," (still using means,) "he—bowed himself to the ground seven times, until he came near to his brother. And Esau ran to meet him; and embraced him, and fell on his neck and kissed him; and they wept." Behold the blessed effects of trusting in God and committing one's self to him in prayer when all other helpers fail. On the same spot that had been sanctified by his prayers, he received this great deliverance. The same clod that had been just wet with praying tears, was now sprinkled with the tears of brother affection.— Who will ever again distrust the faithfulness or resources of that God who could thus extract its venom from the scorpion's sting and soften an Esau into a brother. Penuel is the place where all should seek relief, as they have occasion, from the dangers and trials of life.

"Thy name shall be called—Israel; for as a prince hast thou power with God and with men." The very name of Israel signifies one who prevails with God: and the application of this name to the whole Church is a standing memorial of their potency in prayer. Great is Israel's weight and prevalence in heaven. And they will prevail with men; will prevail over all their enemies,—over all the profane Esaus who throw away their own birthright and then follow their "brother with the sword." Yes, great is Israel's weight and prevalence in heaven. And so long as they retain this name, their influence will never cease. It is a mark put upon them to betoken that they are invincible, (I had almost said, almighty,) in prayer. For by prayer they take hold of almighty strength and appropriate it to their benefit.

My object in this sermon is to show that by prayer believers really affect the heart of God.

It seems to be too common an opinion that God acts from the dictates of wisdom without feeling, or at least that he has no feelings for individuals, but only a benevolence for the universe at large. but how can he love the whole and not the parts? It is sometimes said that prayer is designed merely to fit men for blessings, not to influence God. If by fitting men for blessings is meant that it awakens in them those feelings which please and affect the mind of God, and render him unwilling to deny their requests, then prayer truly fits them for the blessings. But what will yous ay when prayer brings down blessing on others who never prayed, and who live in distant quarters of the globe. The good bestowed in such a case is no personal benefit to the prayerful. It is objected that God causes the exercises which are put forth in prayer, and that he cannot be affected by what he himself produces. But he created men and angels, who are none the less the objects of his love on that account. Will the objector say that God has no delight in the holiness of creatures because he himself has caused it? And if he can love the creatures which he has made and the holiness which he has caused, why can he not be affected by the prayers which he has excited? Every man has an individuation of existence as distinct from God as from Gabriel, and has a consciousness of pleasure as distinct from that which is attached to the divine mind as it is from the happiness of Paul. Our persons, our character, our desires, our happiness, are all as interesting to God as though he had not created or sanctified us,—as though we were self existent.

The Scriptures speak of God as though he was really affected by prayer,—as though, from infinite and direct tenderness towards his children individually, he could not deny their requests, except so far as their good and the public interest require it. Are these representations merely after the manner of men, as we speak of his eyes and hands and feet, or do they hold forth literal and exact realities?

One thing is certain: the experience of creatures can never prove that these representations are not literally true. The conduct of God will always correspond with that of a parent who is actually prevailed upon by the entreaties of his children. They go to him, ask, and receive; receive what they would not have had if they had not asked for it. They who bear the name of Israel have the same power to prevail with God that Jacob had at Penuel. The Angel of the covenant acted as though he could not break away from the eager patriarch. The effect was the same as though he could not. So it is with the struggle of other saints. How often is the appearance strongly held out that "the effectual fervent prayer of a righteous man availeth much." Zion in prayer appears absolutely invincible. By prayer she slew a hundred and eighty-five thousand of Sennacherib's army at a stroke. By prayer she destroyed the immense army of Moab in the days of Jehoshaphat. By prayer she slew a hundred and twenty thousand of the Midianites, while Gideon and the three hundred men with him only blew their trumpets and broke their pitchers and stood still in their place. By prayer she ovethrew Pharaoh and his host in the Red Sea. By prayer she vanquished the Amalekites at Rephiddim. By prayer she demolished the walls of Jerico. And the time would fail me to tell of the overthrow of the Canaanites, the Philistines, Edom, Ammon, and Syria, and all the conquests which prayer has made. When prayer has put her hand to the sword, "one" has chased "a thousand, and two" have "put then thousand to flight." Thus have Israel power to prevail with men. And the history of the Church proves that they have power to prevail with God.

What power had Abraham to prevail with God, when by successive entreaties he obtained his promise to spare the wicked Sodom if there were in it fifty righteous men,—if forty-five,—if forty,—if thirty,—if twenty,—and even if ten. In repeated instances, when the patience of God seemed exhausted by the rebellions in the wilderness, Moses prevailed with him to reverse the exterminating sentence. Joshua prevailed with God to cause the sun and moon to stand still. Gideon prevailed with him to confirm his faith by the fleece and the dew, and to vary the sign at his solicitation. Hannah prevailed with him to give the long desired son to her maternal arms. Samuel prevailed with him to rock the pole with thunders and to deluge the earth with rain, as a reproving sign to the rebellious Hebrews. Elijah by his prayers stopped the windows of heaven, that "it rained not on the earth by the space of three years and six months." Again he prayed, "and the heaven gave rain and the earth brought forth her fruit." Hezekiah prevailed on God to reverse the sentence of death which had gone out against him, and for a confirming sign to carry back the shadow of the sun ten degrees. By prayer Daniel obtained secrets from God who no other man could discover, stopped the mouths of lions, and brought down angels to unfold the counsels of heaven. The three children prevailed on God to quench the rage of the seven times heated furnace. Esther and the Jews prevailed on him to blunt all the bolts of Persian thunder, and to raise his people to triumph from the very gates of death. While the disciples were assembled to pray for the imprisoned Peter, the angel of the Lord entered his prison, smote off his chains, and brought him out. Paul and Silas by their prayers raised an earthquake which burst open all the prison doors, and shook off all their bands, and brought the jailer to the foot of the cross. When the apostles and their "company" were praying bout the persecuting priest and elders, "the place was shaken,—and they were all filled with the Holy Ghost." "And what shall I more say? for the time would fail me to tell" of the millions who through prayer "subdued kingdoms,—obtained promises,—escaped the edge of the sword,—waxed valiant in fight, turned to flight the armies of the aliens."

It was because they bore the name of Israel and as a prince had power to prevail with God. And all who bear this name are addressed by God in this wonderful language, "Command ye me." [cf. Isa. 45:11]

We must therefore conclude that God is as really affected by the supplications of his children as any earthly parent is. Indeed he says this in so many words. "If a son shall ask bread of any of you that is a father, will he give him a stone? or if he ask a fish will he—give him a serpent? or if he shall ask an egg will he offer him a scorpion? If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children, how much more shall your heavenly Father give the holy Spirit to them that ask him."— Do you who are parents feel that you cannot deny your children anything which they discreetly ask and which you are able to bestow? The same feelings has God. "I say discreetly ask; for they sometimes make indiscreet requests for things that would injure them; in which case, however disposed to indulgence, you do not yield to their solicitations. So it is with God. He does not grant his people what would injure them or mar the public good; but he will grant them something better. When Paul thrice prayed for the removal of the thorn in his flesh, he was not answered in exact form, but in the bestowment of greater good. "And he said unto me, My grace is sufficient for thee, for my strength is made perfect in weakness. Most gladly therefore will I rather glory in my infirmities, that the power of Christ may rest upon me."

The grand objection to the theory that God is really affected by prayer, arises from an apprehension that this would militate against his unchangeableness. I therefore say, that he has none of the fickleness and weakness of earthly parents when they are moved by the entreaties of their children. Their emotions are new and temporary, and often partial and unwise. Under the temporary excitement they are hurried into feelings and actions which are injurious to their children and unjust to others. Not so with God. Why, I ask, would it be more inconsistent with his immutability to be affected by the prayers of his children, than to feel compassion for their sufferings, or complacency in their holiness, or benevolence for their persons and desires for their happiness? All these feelings must be new and imply change unless they have existed in one eternal now. And if without change he can feel this compassion and complacency and benevolence towards his children, why, without change, can he not be affected by their prayers?

The grand truth is, that God's existence is not in succession, but in one eternal now. To suppose otherwise would impute to him imperfection, and deny his immutability, omniscience, and infinity. If he exists in succession he is constantly receiving new ideas; and then there is a change of thought, which must lead to a change of counsel. If he is eternally receiving new ideas, he is not in possession of all ideas at once, and therefore is not omniscient. If hew ideas are constantly coming into his mind, either the old ones are crowded out and forgotten, or he must grow in knowledge. On either supposition he is not infinite.

We cannot avoid the conclusion then that God's existence is not in succession but in one eternal now. Whatever feelings therefore he has, he had from eternity. Whatever objects are now present to his mind, were always present. With him there is nothing new. His children were individually before him from eternity, and his heart was always affected with benevolence towards them, with love for their holiness and compassion for their sufferings; and with equal certainty it was always affected by their prayers. He eternally and unchangeably beheld them before him, eternally and unchangeably heard their prayers, and eternally and unchangeably felt those yearnings of tenderness which could not deny their consistent requests.— Prayer can have the same influence with him as though he had not what creatures call foreknowledge and foredetermination,— as though he never existed till to-day. We may go to him with as much confidence as we would go to an earthly parent, who could be not only impressed but changed by our entreaties.

What a glorious circumstance it is that there is such a God,—enthroned in infinite majesty, yet from the midst of whose radiant glories divine compassion looks out as from a thousand eyes, and melts with pity for a dying world,—with more than a father's tenderness for his children. O such a God! Who can stifle the bursting praise? Who can hold their tongue from running loose in anthems of thanksgiving? Infinite ocean of love! real, unbounded love! let us love and adore and delight in thee as we may, as we ought, as we must.

We see then with what spirit and expectations we ought to pray;—not with a view to change God, but to become such objects as he eternally and unchangeably loved, and to present such petitions as he eternally and unchangeably felt unable to deny.

Still our prayers must be made with entire submission. No condescending language of God as if subjecting himself to our dictation,—no consciousness of power to influence him,—should make us forget that he has a sovereign right to do with us as seemeth good in his sight. Even his best beloved Son must say, "Not my will but thine be done."

We cannot be exclaim what admiration and transport, what a glorious privilege is prayer.—How unspeakable the privilege of approaching that heart which is full of tendernesses like these, and of gaining over that power which "openeth and no man shutteth," which "shutteth and no man openeth."

With all the energy of wrestling Jacob let us embrace and hold fast a prayer-hearing God. Had we the patriarch's strength of faith, our prayers would not be languid and unavailing; nor should we so irresolutely give over the struggle when God for a moment seems to reject our petitions,—an appearance which he sometimes puts on on purpose to try the strength of our faith and desire? Had Jacob been thus irresolute, he would have missed the blessing on the banks of Jabbok and his name would never have been called Israel. What powerful motives rush upon us to "pray without ceasing" What motives to union in prayer. If Jacob alone was so invincible, how great might be the united strength of praying thousands. Ere God "shall appear in his glory" to "build up Zion," there must be many wrestling Jacobs. The inscription is written on the broad side of heaven, "I will yet for this be inquired of by the house of Israel to do it for them."

Let the subject come down with the weight of a thousand thunders upon the prayerless. Do they know the incalculable loss they sustain by neglecting prayer? Worlds could not countervail the damage. And do they weigh the infinite guilt incurred by refusing the tendered compassions of a God? Heaven itself cries aloud, "Seek ye the Lord while he may be found; call ye upon him while he is near." Have you determined to reject his love and the immortal happiness which is opening upon you, and to defy his resentments, to breast his power, and to lie down in everlasting burnings? If so, then proceed and put your dreadful resolution to the test. But O that it may waver; O that it may change. O that Gabriel and Paul and all the saints above may strike a higher note as they see you on your faces, as they hear you cry with bursting tears, "God be merciful to me a sinner." Amen.



More sermons by Edward D. Griffin at the www.puritansermons.com HERE
Sermons there include "When I Was A Child"; "Heaven"; "Enoch Walked With God"

Google books:
Sermons by the Late Rev. Edward D. Griffin, D.D. volume 1 HERE
Sermons by the Late Rev. Edward D. Griffin D. D. volume 2 HERE

Fifty-Four Plain Practical Sermons by the Late Edward D. Griffin, D.D. HERE

Sermons, Not Before Published, on Various Practical Subjects by the Late Edward D. Griffin HERE
(apparently another version of the previous book)

My Gospel Meals blog